Study: The Holiday Foods Americans Love, Hate, and Remember Most

November 10, 2026
Written By SolitaireStreak

The turkey may be the centerpiece, but when it comes to holiday meals, the food people look forward to most isn’t always the main course. Sometimes it’s the mashed potatoes, the rolls, or a dessert someone in the family has been making for decades.

Of course, every family has its disagreements about what belongs on the holiday table. And once everyone sits down to eat, the conversation can be just as memorable as the food.

At SolitaireStreak, we wanted to learn more about what Americans love and dislike about Thanksgiving and Christmas gatherings. We surveyed people across the country about their favorite and least favorite holiday foods, the dishes that bring back their strongest memories, the topics they dread discussing with family, and more.

Here’s what we found.

Key Takeaways

  • Mashed potatoes are America’s favorite holiday food, liked by more than 96% of people who have tried them at both Thanksgiving and Christmas.
  • Turkey brings back the strongest holiday food memories, named by 21.2% of respondents who shared a memory about a specific dish.
  • Plant-based roast is the most disliked food at both Thanksgiving and Christmas, followed by goose.
  • 83.5% of Americans dread at least one topic of conversation at holiday meals, with politics topping the list.
  • More than half of Americans (53.4%) have skipped a holiday gathering entirely to avoid family tension.
  • Massachusetts leads for alcohol consumption on Thanksgiving, while Illinois takes the top spot on Christmas.

Americans’ Favorite Holiday Dishes

From turkey and ham to pies and cookies, the holidays bring out all kinds of foods that don’t make regular appearances throughout the year. To find out which ones Americans enjoy most, we asked people about 28 Thanksgiving dishes and 40 Christmas dishes, ranking each one by the percentage of people who like it among those who have tried it.

The Holiday Foods Americans Love Most

The Thanksgiving and Christmas dishes Americans enjoy most, among those who’ve had each one

RankDish% who like it
1Mashed potatoes96.3%
2Bread rolls96.0%
3Macaroni and cheese89.7%
4Biscuits89.3%
5Gravy86.9%
6Turkey86.5%
7Apple pie85.4%
8Stuffing83.4%
9Ham77.5%
10Pumpkin pie73.5%
10Pot roast73.5%
12Potato rolls72.5%
13Deviled eggs72.2%
14Prime rib71.0%
15Glazed carrots69.7%
16Pecan pie66.4%
17Sweet potato casserole64.9%
18Green bean casserole64.3%
19Creamed corn64.3%
20Cranberry sauce62.6%
21Brussels sprouts60.3%
22Candied yams55.6%
23Bread pudding54.0%
24Sweet potato pie53.5%
25Duck30.0%
26Tofu27.6%
27Goose13.4%
28Plant-based roast12.4%
Scroll to see all 28 dishes
RankDish% who like it
1Mashed potatoes96.1%
2Bread rolls95.8%
3Christmas cookies95.0%
4Roast potatoes94.1%
5Biscuits89.5%
5Macaroni and cheese89.5%
7Gravy86.5%
8Chocolate fudge85.5%
9Scalloped potatoes85.2%
10Turkey85.0%
11Stuffing83.9%
12Red velvet cake80.3%
13Roast beef79.5%
14Mixed nuts79.1%
15Ham78.6%
16Gingerbread73.8%
17Pot roast73.6%
18Potato rolls73.2%
19Prime rib72.1%
20Candy canes72.0%
21Hot apple cider69.3%
21Pigs in a blanket69.3%
23Glazed carrots69.1%
24Peppermint bark65.6%
25Fish64.9%
26Creamed corn64.7%
27Green bean casserole64.2%
28Cranberry sauce62.7%
29Sweet potato casserole62.6%
30Brussels sprouts59.9%
31Eggnog56.4%
32Candied yams56.0%
33Brie49.3%
34Lamb41.1%
35Fruitcake32.1%
36Duck30.2%
37Tofu26.9%
38Goose14.2%
39Plant-based roast12.8%
40Persimmon pudding11.5%
Scroll to see all 40 dishes

Percentages based on Americans who have had each food.

Holiday Table Showdowns
Thanksgiving protein
86.5%Turkey
VS
77.5%Ham
Thanksgiving pie
85.4%Apple pie
VS
73.5%Pumpkin pie
Christmas drink
69.3%Hot apple cider
VS
56.4%Eggnog
Solitaire Streak

Mashed potatoes take first place at both holidays, liked by 96.3% of Americans who have eaten them at Thanksgiving and 96.1% at Christmas. Bread rolls finish a close second on both lists, with approval ratings of 96.0% and 95.8%, respectively.

At Thanksgiving, macaroni and cheese (89.7%), biscuits (89.3%), and gravy (86.9%) round out the top five. Turkey comes in sixth at 86.5%, well ahead of ham at 77.5%.

Christmas has a few different favorites. Christmas cookies rank third at 95.0%, followed by roast potatoes at 94.1%. Biscuits and macaroni and cheese tie for fifth at 89.5%. Turkey and ham are popular here, too, earning approval ratings of 85.0% and 78.6%.

We also found a few clear winners in familiar holiday food debates. At Thanksgiving, apple pie beats pumpkin pie by nearly 12 percentage points, with 85.4% liking apple pie compared to 73.5% for pumpkin. At Christmas, hot apple cider (69.3%) is more popular than eggnog (56.4%).

The Holiday Dishes That Bring Back Memories

A favorite food isn’t necessarily the one people remember most. We also asked Americans to name the holiday dish that brings back their strongest memory and explain why.

Among 1,019 written responses, turkey was mentioned most often (21.2%), followed by stuffing or dressing (18.2%). Sweet potato dishes and ham tied for third at 8.2%, followed by Christmas cookies at 7.0%.

The reasons behind those memories tell us something about what makes holiday food special. Family traditions appeared in 33.0% of the responses, while 23.3% mentioned Mom and 22.9% mentioned a grandparent.

Some memories were about cooking together, like making tamales around the kitchen table or spending an evening frosting Christmas cookies. Others involved family jokes, unexpected discoveries, or taking over a recipe from a loved one.

We collected some of our favorite responses below.

The Holiday Dishes Behind Americans’ Strongest Memories

We asked Americans which holiday dish brings back their strongest memory, and why

The Dishes That Take Us Back
RankDish% who named it
1Turkey21.2%
2Stuffing or dressing18.2%
3Sweet potato dishes8.2%
4Ham8.2%
5Christmas cookies7.0%
6Pumpkin pie6.5%
7Mashed potatoes6.4%
8Macaroni and cheese4.7%
33.0%point to family tradition
23.3%mention Mom
22.9%mention a grandparent
Deal Yourself a Holiday Memory

Based on 1,019 write-in responses that named a specific dish and gave a reason. Responses could mention more than one dish or theme. Quotes lightly trimmed for length.

Solitaire Streak

Americans’ Most Hated Holiday Dishes

Every holiday table seems to have a dish that people politely pass over. We wanted to know which foods Americans are most likely to skip, so we ranked the same Thanksgiving and Christmas dishes by the percentage of people who dislike them.

The Holiday Foods Americans Hate Most

The Thanksgiving and Christmas dishes Americans would rather pass on, among those who’ve had each one

RankDish% who don’t like it
1Plant-based roast66.9%
2Goose62.1%
3Tofu59.6%
4Duck47.8%
5Candied yams36.3%
6Sweet potato pie35.6%
7Brussels sprouts35.2%
8Cranberry sauce34.5%
9Bread pudding31.8%
10Green bean casserole31.3%
11Creamed corn30.7%
12Pecan pie29.2%
13Sweet potato casserole29.0%
14Glazed carrots24.8%
15Deviled eggs24.3%
16Pumpkin pie24.0%
17Ham20.8%
18Pot roast20.6%
18Prime rib20.6%
20Stuffing15.4%
21Apple pie13.4%
22Turkey13.1%
23Gravy12.5%
24Potato rolls11.5%
25Macaroni and cheese9.7%
26Biscuits8.9%
27Bread rolls3.6%
28Mashed potatoes3.3%
Scroll to see all 28 dishes
RankDish% who don’t like it
1Plant-based roast67.8%
2Goose62.0%
3Fruitcake60.8%
3Tofu60.8%
5Persimmon pudding59.1%
6Duck48.2%
7Lamb40.4%
8Eggnog38.5%
9Candied yams36.3%
10Brussels sprouts35.6%
11Cranberry sauce34.4%
12Green bean casserole31.6%
13Sweet potato casserole30.9%
14Fish30.8%
15Brie30.6%
16Creamed corn30.3%
17Peppermint bark28.0%
18Candy canes27.1%
19Glazed carrots25.7%
20Hot apple cider24.5%
21Gingerbread23.9%
22Pigs in a blanket22.9%
23Pot roast20.8%
24Prime rib20.1%
25Ham19.8%
26Mixed nuts18.2%
27Red velvet cake16.8%
28Roast beef16.4%
29Stuffing14.9%
30Turkey14.3%
31Chocolate fudge12.6%
32Gravy12.5%
33Potato rolls12.2%
34Scalloped potatoes10.7%
35Macaroni and cheese9.6%
36Biscuits8.8%
37Christmas cookies4.4%
38Roast potatoes4.2%
39Bread rolls3.7%
40Mashed potatoes3.5%
Scroll to see all 40 dishes

Percentages based on Americans who have had each food.

The Most Disliked Dish in Every Course
Main66.9%Plant-based roast
Side36.3%Candied yams
Dessert35.6%Sweet potato pie
Main67.8%Plant-based roast
Side36.3%Candied yams
Dessert60.8%Fruitcake
Drink38.5%Eggnog

Gen Z are more than three times as likely as Baby Boomers to dislike stuffing (26.4% vs. 7.6%).

Solitaire Streak

Plant-based roast is the least popular food at both holidays, disliked by 66.9% of people who have tried it at Thanksgiving and 67.8% at Christmas.

Goose comes in second on both lists, disliked by roughly 62% of those who have eaten it. Tofu also ranks among the least popular choices, with about 60% disliking it at either holiday.

Beyond those dishes, the rankings include plenty of traditional holiday foods that divide opinion.

At Thanksgiving, candied yams are the most disliked side dish at 36.3%, followed closely by Brussels sprouts (35.2%) and cranberry sauce (34.5%). Sweet potato pie leads the disliked desserts at 35.6%, while nearly a third of Americans who have tried green bean casserole (31.3%) aren’t fans.

Christmas brings its own unpopular foods. Fruitcake lives up to its reputation, with 60.8% of people who have tried it saying they don’t like it. Persimmon pudding isn’t far behind at 59.1%. Eggnog also has plenty of critics, with 38.5% disliking the traditional holiday drink.

Some opinions about holiday food change considerably with age. Stuffing is a good example: 26.4% of Gen Z respondents dislike it, compared with just 7.6% of baby boomers. That makes younger Americans more than three times as likely to turn it down.

The safest choices for a holiday menu appear to be the simplest ones. Mashed potatoes and bread rolls finish at the very bottom of both most-disliked lists, with fewer than 4% of people who have tried them reporting that they don’t like them.

Topics We Dread Discussing at Holiday Meals

Holiday gatherings aren’t always easy, even when everyone agrees on the menu. Family dinners can bring up questions and disagreements that people would rather avoid, especially when relatives haven’t seen each other in a while.

We asked Americans which topics they dread discussing at holiday meals, along with the things they’ve done to escape family tension.

Pass the Potatoes, Skip the Questions

The topics Americans dread at holiday meals, and how they escape family tension

The Topics Americans Dread Most at Holiday Meals
RankTopic% who dread it
1Politics56.8%
2Weight or appearance40.2%
3Money37.0%
4Career or job34.2%
5Religion30.3%
6Relationship status27.8%
7Having kids21.2%
8School or grades8.7%

Note: 16.5% of Americans selected “None of the above.”

83.5%

of Americans dread being asked about at least one topic at holiday meals, and women are far more likely than men to dread questions about their weight or appearance (45.4% vs. 29.2%).

How Americans Escape Family Tension During the Holidays
RankWhat they have done% who have done it
1Skipped a gathering entirely53.4%
2Volunteered for dishes or cleanup to escape52.8%
3Pretended to be busy on my phone51.2%
4Hid in another room50.4%
5Left a gathering early48.0%
6Drank more alcohol than usual29.2%
7Started an argument18.1%
1 in 2

Americans have hidden in another room to escape family tension during the holidays, and 52.8% have volunteered for the dishes to get away.

Solitaire Streak

Politics is the most dreaded topic by a considerable margin, with 56.8% of Americans saying they’d rather avoid it at holiday meals.

Questions about weight or appearance come in second at 40.2%, followed by money (37.0%) and careers or jobs (34.2%). Religion (30.3%), relationship status (27.8%), and having kids (21.2%) are also common sources of discomfort.

Women are particularly likely to dread questions about weight or appearance. Nearly half (45.4%) say they dislike these conversations, compared with 29.2% of men.

Overall, 83.5% of Americans dread being asked about at least one of the topics we included in our survey.

And when conversations get uncomfortable, people have found plenty of ways to get away.

More than half of Americans (53.4%) have skipped a holiday gathering entirely to avoid family tension. Almost as many (52.8%) have volunteered to wash dishes or help with cleanup just to get away from the conversation.

Phones offer another escape. More than half (51.2%) have pretended to be busy on their phones, while 50.4% have hidden in another room. Another 48.0% have left a gathering early.

Some people have responded in less subtle ways. Nearly 3 in 10 Americans (29.2%) have drunk more alcohol than usual to deal with family tension during the holidays, and 18.1% admit they’ve started an argument themselves.

Where Americans Drink the Most on Thanksgiving and Christmas

Alcohol is a familiar part of many holiday gatherings, but how much people drink varies from state to state.

Among Americans who drink alcohol, the national average on Thanksgiving is 1.83 drinks. Massachusetts leads the country at 2.37 drinks per person, closely followed by Ohio (2.36) and New York (2.31). Georgia and Oregon tie for fourth at 2.28.

Christmas has a different leader. Illinois takes first place, with drinkers averaging 2.71 alcoholic beverages. Massachusetts comes in second at 2.59, followed by New York and Ohio, tied at 2.51.

Georgia, Oregon, Michigan, New Jersey, Washington, and Florida also appear among the 10 highest-drinking states at both holidays.

The map below shows how holiday drinking compares across states for Thanksgiving and Christmas. These averages include only respondents who drink alcohol, and states without enough responses were excluded.

Where Americans Drink the Most on the Holidays

Average number of alcoholic drinks Americans who drink have on Thanksgiving and Christmas, by state

AlabamaAlaskaArizonaColoradoFloridaGeorgiaIndianaKansasMaineMassachusettsMinnesotaNew JerseyNorth CarolinaNorth DakotaOklahomaPennsylvaniaSouth DakotaTexasWyomingConnecticutMissouriWest VirginiaIllinoisNew MexicoArkansasCaliforniaDelawareHawaiiIowaKentuckyMarylandMichiganMississippiMontanaNew HampshireNew YorkOhioOregonTennesseeUtahVirginiaWashingtonWisconsinNebraskaSouth CarolinaIdahoNevadaVermontLouisianaRhode IslandALAKAZCOFLGAINKSMEMNNCNDOKPASDTXWYMOWVILNMARCAHIIAKYMIMSMTNYOHORTNUTVAWAWINESCIDNVLAVTNHMARICTNJDEMD
1.12.7+Not enough responses
National average1.83drinks on Thanksgiving
Top 10 states, avg. drinks
1Massachusetts2.37
2Ohio2.36
3New York2.31
4Georgia2.28
4Oregon2.28
 
6Michigan2.20
7Florida2.17
7New Jersey2.17
9Washington2.15
10Illinois2.10
Top 10 states, avg. drinks
1Illinois2.71
2Massachusetts2.59
3New York2.51
3Ohio2.51
5Georgia2.48
 
6Oregon2.41
7Michigan2.37
8New Jersey2.35
8Washington2.35
10Florida2.34

Averages exclude respondents who never drink alcohol. States not included due to lack of responses: Alaska, Delaware, Hawaii, Montana, New Hampshire, North Dakota, Rhode Island, South Dakota, Vermont, and Wyoming.

Solitaire Streak

Enjoy a Little Downtime This Holiday Season

Whether your family serves all your favorite dishes or a few you’d rather skip, the holidays are full of familiar traditions, memorable meals, and plenty of time spent together.

They can also get busy, and sometimes a few quiet minutes to yourself are welcome.

If you’re waiting for dinner, relaxing after guests leave, or taking a short break between holiday plans, SolitaireStreak has free online games like Solitaire, Spider Solitaire, and FreeCell to help you pass the time.

Methodology

For this study, SolitaireStreak surveyed Americans about their Thanksgiving and Christmas food preferences, holiday memories, family conversations, ways of handling holiday tension, and alcohol consumption.

Food rankings are based on the percentage of respondents who said they liked or disliked each dish among those who had tried it.

The holiday food memories analysis is based on 1,019 written responses that named a specific dish and provided a reason. Responses could mention more than one dish or theme.

Alcohol consumption averages exclude respondents who never drink alcohol. Ten states were excluded from the state-level analysis due to insufficient responses: Alaska, Delaware, Hawaii, Montana, New Hampshire, North Dakota, Rhode Island, South Dakota, Vermont, and Wyoming.